SPECIAL REPORT: "Tortured Logic: McGovern talks about Gina Haspel, the new CIA director"

The Resistance Round Table panel interviews former CIA analyst Ray McGovern about Gina Haspel, the new CIA director who oversaw torture after 9/11. The conversation includes discussion of the U.S. as an 'out law state,' American exceptionalism and the fight to defend net neutrality. Panel: Scott Harris, Ruthanne Baumgartner and Richard Hill (49:08) May 23, 2018

SPECIAL REPORT: "MIT Students' 'Day of Action': Understanding and Resisting Attacks on Immigrants"

Three-part excerpts from Avi Chomsky's presentations at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology's Day of Action on April 17. Includes a historical perspective as well as a question and answer session with immigrants. Recorded and produced by Chuck Rosina, long-time public affairs and news producer at WMBR FM, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology's radio station in Cambridge, Massachusetts. April 17, 2018

SPECIAL REPORT: "MIT Students' 'Day of Action' Takes On Today's Political, Economic Challenges"

Chuck Rosina's report on the Massachusetts Institute of Technology's Day of Action on April 17, where members of the MIT and broader local community were given an opportunity to devote the day to engaging with the political, economic, environmental and social challenges facing us today, through learning, discussion, reflection and planning for action. Includes comments from Avi Chomsky, daughter of the renowned professor Noam Chomsky (12:58) April 17, 2018

SPECIAL REPORT: "Response to chemical attack in Syria – The priority must be the people"

The Resistance Roundtable panel discusses the U.S. missile strikes on Damascus and interviews Stan Heller from Promoting Enduring Peace ( the situation in Syria and the broader Middle East. Panel: Ruthanne Baumgartner, Scott Harris and Richard Hill. April 14, 2018

SPECIAL REPORT: "What's next for the youth movement against gun violence?"

Tyler Suarez, lead organizer of the March for Our Lives demo in Hartford, CT on March 24, assesses the event attended by 10,000 and discusses the agenda for the youth movement going forward. Interviewed by Richard Hill.

SPECIAL REPORT: "March for Our Lives - Hartford, Connecticut" March 24, 2018

Selected speeches from the March for Our Lives in Hartford, Connecticut, recorded and produced by Scott Harris

Panel Discussion: Privatization v. Public Good and the Upcoming March for Our Lives on March 24

SPECIAL REPORT: Organized Labor: Resurgent or On the Ropes?

SPECIAL REPORT: Neoliberalism Comes Home: Connecticut's Water Under Privatization Threat

SPECIAL REPORT: Can There Be Food Justice Under Capitalism?

SPECIAL REPORT: Resistance Round Table – Feb. 10, 2018

Award-winning Investigative Journalist Robert Parry (1949-2018)

Award-winning investigative journalist and founder/editor of, Robert Parry has passed away. His ground-breaking work uncovering Reagan-era dirty wars in Central America and many other illegal and immoral policies conducted by successive administrations and U.S. intelligence agencies, stands as an inspiration to all in journalists working in the public interest.

Robert had been a regular guest on our Between The Lines and Counterpoint radio shows -- and many other progressive outlets across the U.S. over four decades.

His penetrating analysis of U.S. foreign policy and international conflicts will be sorely missed, and not easily replaced. His son Nat Parry writes a tribute to his father: Robert Parry’s Legacy and the Future of Consortiumnews.

Thank you for donating

If you've made a donation and wish to receive thank you gifts for your donation, be sure to send us your mailing address via our Contact form.

See our thank you gifts for your donation.

The Resistance Starts Now!

Between The Lines' coverage and resource compilation of the Resistance Movement

SPECIAL REPORT: "The Resistance - Women's March 2018 - Hartford, Connecticut" Jan. 20, 2018

Selected speeches from the Women's March in Hartford, Connecticut 2018, recorded and produced by Scott Harris

SPECIAL REPORT: "No Fracking Waste in CT!" Jan. 14, 2018

SPECIAL REPORT: "Resistance Round Table: The Unraveling Continues..." Jan. 13, 2018

SPECIAL REPORT: "Capitalism to the ash heap?" Richard Wolff, Jan. 2, 2018

SPECIAL REPORT: Maryn McKenna, author of "Big Chicken", Dec. 7, 2017

SPECIAL REPORT: Nina Turner's address, Working Families Party Awards Banquet, Dec. 14, 2017

SPECIAL REPORT: Mic Check, Dec. 12, 2017

SPECIAL REPORT: Resistance Roundtable, Dec. 9, 2017

SPECIAL REPORT: On Tyranny - one year later, Nov. 28, 2017

SPECIAL REPORT: Mic Check, Nov. 12, 2017

SPECIAL REPORT: Resistance Roundtable, Nov. 11, 2017

SPECIAL REPORT: Rainy Day Radio, Nov. 7, 2017

SPECIAL REPORT: Rainy Day Radio, Nov. 7, 2017

SPECIAL REPORT: Resisting U.S. JeJu Island military base in South Korea, Oct. 24, 2017

SPECIAL REPORT: John Allen, Out in New Haven

2017 Gandhi Peace Awards

Promoting Enduring Peace presented its Gandhi Peace Award jointly to renowned consumer advocate Ralph Nader and BDS founder Omar Barghouti on April 23, 2017.

Subscribe to our Weekly Summary & receive our FREE Resist Trump window cling

resist (Car window cling)

Email us with your mailing address at to receive our "Resist Trump/Resist Hate" car window cling!


who helped make our 25th anniversary with Jeremy Scahill a success!

For those who missed the event, or were there and really wanted to fully absorb its import, here it is in video

Jeremy Scahill keynote speech, part 1 from PROUDEYEMEDIA on Vimeo.

Jeremy Scahill keynote speech, part 2 from PROUDEYEMEDIA on Vimeo.

Between The Lines on Stitcher


Between The Lines Presentation at the Left Forum 2016

"How Do We Build A Mass Movement to Reverse Runaway Inequality?" with Les Leopold, author of "Runaway Inequality: An Activist's Guide to Economic Justice,"May 22, 2016, John Jay College of Criminal Justice, The City University of New York, 860 11th Ave. (Between 58th and 59th), New York City. Between The Lines' Scott Harris and Richard Hill moderated this workshop. Listen to the audio/slideshows and more from this workshop.

Listen to audio of the plenary sessions from the weekend.

JEREMY SCAHILL: Oscar-nominated documentary filmmaker "Dirty Wars"

Listen to the full interview (30:33) with Jeremy Scahill, an award-winning investigative journalist with the Nation Magazine, correspondent for Democracy Now! and author of the bestselling book, "Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary Army," about America's outsourcing of its military. In an exclusive interview with Counterpoint's Scott Harris on Sept. 16, 2013, Scahill talks about his latest book, "Dirty Wars, The World is a Battlefield," also made into a documentary film under the same title, and was nominated Dec. 5, 2013 for an Academy Award in the Best Documentary Feature category.

Listen to Scott Harris Live on WPKN Radio

Between The Lines' Executive Producer Scott Harris hosts a live, weekly talk show, Counterpoint, from which some of Between The Lines' interviews are excerpted. Listen every Monday evening from 8 to 10 p.m. EDT at (Follows the 5-7 minute White Rose Calendar.)

Counterpoint in its entirety is archived after midnight ET Monday nights, and is available for at least a year following broadcast in WPKN Radio's Archives.

You can also listen to full unedited interview segments from Counterpoint, which are generally available some time the day following broadcast.

Subscribe to Counterpoint bulletins via our subscriptions page.

Between The Lines Blog  BTL Blog

"The Rogue World Order: Connecting the Dots Between Trump, Flynn, Bannon, Spencer, Dugin Putin," by Anna Manzo (GlobalHealing), Daily Kos, Feb. 13, 2017

"Widespread Resistance Begins to Trump's Muslim Travel Ban at U.S. Airports," by Anna Manzo (GlobalHealing), Daily Kos, Jan. 28, 2017

"MSNBC Editor: Women's March is a Revival of the Progressive Movement," by Anna Manzo (GlobalHealing), Daily Kos, Jan. 24, 2017

"Cornering Trump," by Reginald Johnson, Jan. 19, 2017

"Free Leonard Peltier," by Reginald Johnson, Jan. 6, 2016

"For Natives, a "Day of Mourning"by Reginald Johnson, November 23, 2016

"A Bitter Harvest" by Reginald Johnson, Nov. 15, 2016

Special Programming Special Programming

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Between The Lines Progressive Resources

A compilation of activist and news sites with a progressive point of view

Share this content:


Podcasts Subscribe to BTL

Podcasts:  direct  or  via iTunes

Subscribe to Program Summaries, Interview Transcripts or Counterpoint via email or RSS feed

If you have other questions regarding subscriptions, feeds or podcasts/mp3s go to our Audio Help page.

Between The Lines Blog

Stay connected to BTL

RSS feed  twitter  facebook

donate  Learn how to support our efforts!

Civil Liberties Advocates Say Obama's Proposed NSA Surveillance Reforms Don’t Go Far Enough

Real Audio  RealAudio MP3  MP3

Posted Aug. 14, 2013

Interview with Kade Crockford, director of the Technology for Liberty project at the ACLU of Massachusetts, conducted by Scott Harris


It wasn’t long after a surprisingly close vote on legislation in the U.S. House of Representatives that would have defunded the National Security Agency surveillance program that collects massive amounts of data on U.S. citizens’ phone communications, that President Obama came forward in an Aug. 9 press conference to propose his own set of reforms to his administration’s spy programs.

While the president rejected the assertion by many that Edward Snowden, the former NSA contractor who leaked details of his former employer’s surveillance programs was a hero, it was clear that Snowden's revelations were driving the debate on reform in Washington and around the country. Specifically, the president proposed revising Section 215 of the Patriot Act - that gives the government broad authority to collect phone communications records. Obama said he would work with Congress to reconstitute the secretive foreign intelligence surveillance (FISA) court, which grants the NSA legal authorization for its bulk collection of phone and Internet data, to make it more adversarial – and establish a civil liberties advocate to have an unspecified role during court proceedings. Lastly, the president said he’ll require more transparency of the surveillance programs and create a panel of former intelligence officials and privacy advocates to assess the NSA programs and suggest futher reforms.

Between The Lines’ Scott Harris spoke with Kade Crockford, director of the Technology for Liberty project at the ACLU of Massachusetts who assesses the shortcomings in President Obama's NSA reform proposals and suggests the most effective path to safeguard national security without sacrificing liberty and the right to privacy.

KADE CROCKFORD: It's a good thing that president is talking about reforming the surveillance state. It's really unfortunate, however, that his comments were pretty duplicitous, actually. The president only spoke to the 215 program, which is Section 215 of the USA Patriot Act. And this is the statute that authorizes the bulk records collection. For example, the Verizon business order that was disclosed by Edward Snowden and published by The Guardian newspaper.

This kind of order that enables the government to collect in bulk all of them, our of phone records. This is authorized under the 215 program and unfortunately, what President Obama did not say about the 215 program is that it's going to end. The president and the national security establishment appear to believe that this is a necessary instrument in the service of protecting the country. This, although they have not provided any evidence that this is actually the case. The couple of cases that the officials like to trot out in fact are not evidence that 215 was instrumental in there not being any terrorist plots.

And the other proposals that he made are pretty decent, clearly we need more transparency and his comments are pretty vague, so we don't know exactly what he means by "more transparency." You know the idea to have something of an investigation, an inquiry into NSA surveillance is a really big one. The tricky part is, "who's going to be doing that oversight." That is actually really critical. As James Clapper, the head of, the director of national intelligence, is he going to be doing that oversight? I would suggest that's not proper oversight. Someone externally should be investigating. Certainly, the Church Committee in the 1970s, which investigated the COINTELPRO abuses, and NSA abuses, when the NSA was turning its surveillance equipment at the time on American antiwar activists, for example. The Church Committee exposed a lot of those abuses and led to substantial reform for the surveillance state. I do not think that such an inquiry, if it is led by somebody like James Clapper, or former NSA director Michael Hayden would do such a thing. So we really need more details about what the president means with respect to any kind of inquiry.

And finally, the FISA court proposal is a good one, but it's only really a good one if we have changes to the laws that enable the government to conduct broad, warrantless surveillance of Americans. We really have to get rid of Section 215 of the Patriot Act. It should be repealed as well as something the president completely avoided in his remarks, which is 702 of the FISA Amendments Act, and this is the pernicious statute that authorizes warrantless surveillance of the content of Americans' communications, of our international communications. It's the statute that authorizes things like the PRISM program. So the president didn't even mention that at all, and this is troubling in the extreme.

BETWEEN THE LINES: President Obama says he's long an advocate of reforming these surveillance systems, indicating that Edward Snowden's revelations to The Guardian newspaper, the Washington Post, and others, really have nothing to do with it. Why don't you give us your take? What role do you think he played in provoking the White House, the president, to come out with these reform proposals?

KADE CROCKFORD: Well, Edward Snowden clearly played a very essential role. I think everybody in the country is incredibly attuned to the kind of surveillance that the NSA has been conducting only as a result of Edward Snowden's leaks, as a result of him blowing the whistle to the American public about what our government has been doing in the shadows for a number of years.

BETWEEN THE LINES: Kade, what is your prescription for effectively reforming or transforming the nation's surveillance programs to both respect privacy and free speech, while giving the government tools it says it needs to prevent terrorist attacks and other threats?

KADE CROCKFORD: Well, the Fourth Amendment really is the gold standard of American justice. And there's no reason why any surveillance programs can't comport (agree) with the Fourth Amendment. No judge is never going to refuse a legitimate request for surveilling people who the government reasonably believes are involved in some kind of terrorist activity. It's just like a criminal case, right? So the real issue is that we really need to repeal Sections 215 of the Patriot Act, again which is the program that authorizes this bulk record collection. And I just want to say very quickly that Ron White has hinted that it's not just phone records, but may be as well be credit card records in bulk, banking records in bulk, medical records in bulk, even location records in bulk. So we need to repeat Sections 215 of the Patriot Act as well as repeal Section 702 of the FISA Amendments Act, which is what authorizes PRISM, and the warrantless content collection.

Find links to groups actively working to defend civil liberties by visiting the Technology and Liberty project at the Massachusetts chapter of the ACLU at

Related Links: